Wei Fan, Zhang Xiao Yang, Liu Yi Chen
Improving disaster prevention, mitigation and relief capacity, together with the capacity to handle major and urgent public emergencies, has been placed at the core of the national security system and has become a key indicator of progress in modernizing China’s governance system and governance capacity. From 30 June to 6 July 2016, under the influence of a strong El Niño event, Wuhan experienced an exceptionally persistent rainstorm. Cumulative rainfall over the seven-day period reached 560.5 mm, the highest weekly total since meteorological records began; at some stations in Jiangxia District the seven-day total reached 733.7 mm, exceeding the 100-year return period. At the peak of the event, 162 waterlogged sites appeared within the built-up area, expressways and arterial roads were cut off, dikes in the outlying districts of Huangpi and Xinzhou were endangered, and 864,000 residents were affected, with 172,900 person-times emergency relocated, 14 people killed and one missing. The disaster provides a representative case for examining how a large riverside city governed by a local government responds to cumulative, long-duration rainfall rather than to a single short peak.This study constructs a mixed-method framework of “case thick description – comparative analysis – mechanism extraction”. Process tracing is used to reconstruct the full cycle from rainfall onset and warning issuance to emergency response, waterlogging clearance and post-disaster recovery, so as to identify critical decision points and response gaps. An embedded comparison of Wuhan, Changsha and Hefei examines how three provincial capitals in the middle reaches of the Yangtze handle comparable persistent rainfall. Social network analysis is used as an analytical lens for the structure of government–enterprise–society interaction, fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis (fsQCA) for the configurations of conditions associated with effective response across Wuhan’s 13 administrative districts, and latent Dirichlet allocation (LDA) topic modelling for the focus of public attention in news and social media texts. Given the constraints on data access in an undergraduate research project, the last three methods serve mainly as analytical perspectives rather than as fully executed quantitative models; the empirical core rests on process tracing and comparative case analysis based on public reports and secondary textual materials.Four predicaments are identified. The technological embedding predicament appears as a gap between monitoring and warning on the one hand and drainage engineering and organizational routines on the other: warnings were issued repeatedly, yet pumping stations operating at full capacity could not discharge water because of backwater from the high Yangtze and lake levels. The collaborative governance predicament consists of an institutional deficit in the interaction among government, water utilities, communication and power enterprises and social organizations, whose mobilization still depended on ad hoc administrative instruction. The spatial equity predicament reflects an uneven distribution of flood-control resources between the central districts and the outlying districts and townships, where losses and casualties were concentrated. The institutional fragmentation predicament stems from the division of river and lake regulation, urban drainage, meteorological monitoring and disaster relief among separate administrative systems, reinforced by a path dependency that favours emergency rescue over anticipatory prevention. On this basis a three-dimensional interactive model of “vision – system – capacity” is constructed: modernization of vision is the driving force that moves emergency management from post-event relief towards anticipatory risk governance; system rebuilding is the carrier that reallocates authority and integrates procedures; capacity upgrading is the visible outcome across risk assessment, resource dispatch, on-site response and recovery. The three evolve through a closed loop in which vision guides system iteration, the system supports capacity upgrading, and capacity in turn feeds back into vision.Accordingly, optimization pathways are proposed along four dimensions: technology empowerment, government–enterprise collaboration, resilience building and integrated governance. The paper also explores an effectiveness assessment framework informed by the Capability Maturity Model (CMM), offered as a theoretical design rather than a tested tool, to support the diagnosis of emergency management weaknesses in comparable riverside megacities.
Emergency Management Effectiveness; Local Government; Wuhan “7·6” Rainstorm; Process Tracing; Three-Dimensional Interactive Model